Skip to main content

What’s Supposed to Happen After Supreme Court Justice is Nominated


President Donald Trump will announce his nomination for the Supreme Court tonight. So what happens next? You might be wondering, since the last time a President nominated someone for the Supreme Court, well … nothing happened. But under normal circumstances, after a nomination is made, the confirmation process begins. Here’s what that entails.

The first step after a President nominates a potential Supreme Court justice is that the nomination goes to the Senate Judiciary Committee. The Committee then performs research on the candidate, including having them fill out a questionnaire and the nominee meeting with Senators. Merrick Garland went through this process after his nomination, but that’s as far as he got.

The Judiciary Committee then holds a confirmation hearing, at which point they get to question the nominee and vote on whether his nomination will go before the entire Senate. After the hearing, the Judiciary Committee votes on the nomination, and a simple majority of the Committee must vote in favor of the pick in order for them to go before the whole Senate. When Garland was the nominee, Republicans on the Judiciary Committee refused to hold the initial confirmation hearing, and since the GOP has the majority, the hearing never happened.

After the Judiciary Committee vote, assuming they vote in favor of the nomination, the nomination goes before the Senate to officially confirm the nominee as a Supreme Court justice. While Senate confirmation of other government officials requires a simple majority vote, when it comes to the Supreme Court, it’s a little different. A challenge can be made to the confirmation that would require 60 Senators to vote in favor of the nominee. Since there are currently less than 60 Republicans in the Senate, this could result in a Democratic filibuster that would block the nomination.

Of course, it is within the Senate’s power to change the rules before it gets to that. The Senate rules can be changed if a simple majority elects to change them. Former Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid did this in 2013, when he led Democrats to eliminate the filibuster possibility for all Presidential nominations except Supreme Court picks. Now that Republicans control the Senate, current Majority Leader Mitch McConnell could do the same now to make it so SCOTUS picks cannot be blocked by a filibuster. McConnell has indicated that he is not a fan of this option, despite urging from President Trump, but he hasn’t ruled it out.


Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: