Skip to main content

Prosecutors Wrote ‘N’ Next to the Names of Black Jurors Before Striking Them From Jury Pool


Prosecutors in Georgia’s second-largest city routinely wrote “N”s next to the names of potential black jurors in a long-running effort described by defense attorneys as “systematic race discrimination.”

Aside from the somewhat obvious racial implications of the “N” designation, Columbus prosecutors also consistently employed a variety of additional slurs and insults used solely to denote and describe potential black jurors–while describing white jurors in glowing terms and by their occupations.

In February, the Superior Court of Muscogee County ordered the state to disclose prosecutors’ jury selection notes from the capital trials of black defendants overseen by two former Muscogee County prosecutors—Douglas Pullen and William Smith.

The state provided Gates’ defense attorneys the demanded evidence on March 2. Those jury selection notes were summarized in a press release issued by the Southern Center for Human Rights (“SCHR”):

* The prosecutors labeled white prospective jurors as “W” and black prospective jurors as “N.”
* The prosecutors further singled out black prospective jurors for strikes by marking a dot next to the black prospective jurors’ names.
* The prosecutors described black prospective jurors in derogatory terms, including “slow,” “old + ignorant,” “con artist,” “hostile,” and “fat.”
* One white prospective juror was described as a “top juror” because he “has to deal with 150 to 200 of these people that work for his construction co.”

This alleged system of racial discrimination was originally revealed Monday morning in a motion filed by defense attorneys for Johnny Lee Gates, who is currently serving a life sentence for the 1976 rape and murder of Katrina Wright.

Gates’ attorneys are demanding a new trial because prosecutors in his original case systematically worked to keep black people off the jury. Out of four potential black jurors who might have served on Gates’ jury, all four were struck from the jury pool.

Similar efforts by the Muscogee County District Attorney’s Office kept potential black jurors off of juries for six out of seven black death penalty defendants during the 1970s.

Patrick Mulvaney, a lawyer with the SCHR and a member of Gates’ defense team said, in comments to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution:

Every person accused of a criminal offense has the right to a fair trial that’s free of race discrimination. Mr. Gates’s trial was undermined by race discrimination from the start.

Muscogee County District Attorney Julia Slater is resisting the demand for a new trial. The standard her office believes Gates’ defense attorneys need to meet is systematic exclusion of black jurors “in case after case, whatever the circumstances, whatever the crime and whoever the defendant or victim may be,” according to recent court filing.

Defense attorneys for Gates believe the proof is very much in the pudding here and said, in comments to Law&Crime, that the recently-released jury notes show exactly the sort of systematic discrimination Slater’s office is demanding proof of.

Law&Crime reached out to Slater directly for comment but no response was forthcoming at the time of publication.

This isn’t the first time Muscogee County has found itself accused of violating federal law. In 2015, Muscogee County and the Department of Justice entered into a consent agreement for previous widespread violations of the Civil Rights Act.

[image via screengrab]

Follow Colin Kalmbacher on Twitter: @colinkalmbacher

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: