Skip to main content

VERDICT WATCH: Aaron Hernandez Murder Trial — Day 5


The jurors in the double murder trial of Aaron Hernandez we’re unable to reach a decision again after another day of deliberations on Wednesday. The former NFL star is charged with killing two men and injuring a third in a shooting outside a nightclub in Boston in July 2012. Prosecutors allege Hernandez became enraged after one of the victims allegedly spilled a drink on him and never apologized.

The prosecution’s key witness, Alexander Bradley, testified under a grant of immunity that he was driving Hernandez’s SUV on the night of the shootings and that Hernandez reach over and fired five shots, killing Daniel de Abreu and Safir Furtado. A third victim was struck with a bullet, but survived. Months later, prosecutors allege Hernandez then shot Bradley in a failed effort to silence him.

The defense, led by Jose Baez, blamed the Boston Police for shoddy police work because they failed to solve the crime for so many years. He also argued that no physical evidence tied Hernandez to the scene and at least two independent witnesses claimed during police interviews that there may have been a woman in the shooter’s vehicle.

Baez also lashed out hard at Bradley, calling him a turncoat simply looking for the best deal to perhaps get an easier sentence on a 2014 conviction for shooting up a nightclub. Baez also claimed that Bradley was the shooter on the evening of July 2012 and it was all over a drug deal gone bad.

After nearly one and half hours of instructions from the judge, the jurors now hold Hernandez’s fate in their hands.

He has denied any involvement in the 2012 killings. However, he is currently serving a life sentence without parole for the killing of Odin Lloyd. That case is on appeal.

Jurors left the courthouse Wednesday afternoon and were asked to return on Thursday ay 9:00 AM for another day of deliberations, which some lawyers say typically favors the defendant.

Stick with LawNewz to see the verdict live and watch the analysis with our panel of experts.

[image via screengrab]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: