Skip to main content

‘I’m Not For That Third Gender Sh*t’; NY Democrat Accused of Using Transphobic Slur


New York State senator Jesse Hamilton, a Democrat, is under fire after be accused of making anti-transgender comments to a constituent while campaigning for re-election in South Brooklyn on Tuesday morning. His staff says he was misinterpreted.

According to a post by Alejandra Caraballo in the closed Facebook group “Prospect Lefferts Gardens and Brooklyn Neighbors,” Hamilton was pressed about his support for the LGBTQ community. In response, Hamilton allegedly said, “I’m not for that third gender shit.”

Caraballo described how the situation unfolded. In her post, she wrote:

I ran into state senator Jesse Hamilton who was campaigning this morning in front of the Winthrop 2/5 stop. I asked him about GENDA (gender expression non discrimination act) and he tried to say he’s pro-LGBTQ and then literally says to me, “I’m not for that 3rd gender shit.” That just confirmed my vote for Zellnor Myrie.

In later comments, Caraballo was asked whether those were Hamilton’s actual words. She said, “Yes, those were his actual words. He tried attacking Zellnor as not supportive of the LGBTQ community and then casually dropped that line.”

Users in the Facebook group then tagged Raul Rothblatt, Hamilton’s director for community affairs, and asked him to address the transphobic comments. In response, Rothblatt wrote:

Senator Hamilton has been the bravest supporter of LGBTQ+ rights in the New York Senate. Two years ago, he was the first elected official to march with a gay pride group on the Labor Day Parade. To say he is homophobic is not credible. I have heard him in private and in public speaking out against homophobia. Full disclosure: I also was at the same subway station this morning with Jesse.

The group’s users continued to push Rothblatt for an explanation of the morning’s comments–many noting that there is a difference between homophobia and transphobia. Eventually, Rothblatt responded, “I just spoke to Jesse, and he reiterated his statement again which was that he opposes conversation therapy. That was his statement this morning.”

Twitter users denounced Hamilton over the comments.

Socialist activist Seth Pollack criticized the comments, while taking note of Hamilton’s atypical caucus affiliation:

Hamilton is technically a member of the Democratic Party. Somewhat controversially, however, Hamilton does not caucus with most other New York State senate Democrats. Rather, Hamilton and a small group of conservative state senators in New York are part of the so-called “Independent Democratic Conference” which allows the New York State GOP control over the Empire State’s smaller legislative chamber.

Book editor Ron Hogan wrote:

User @batsabatsabatsa also expressed outrage at the comments:

Hamilton is facing a formidable primary challenge by Zellnor Myrie. New York State’s primary election is this Thursday, September 13.

[image via screengrab]

Follow Colin Kalmbacher on Twitter: @colinkalmbacher

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: