Skip to main content

New Hampshire Man Shot and Killed His Grandmother’s 72-Year-Old Husband: Prosecutors


A man shot his grandmother’s husband in the head, leaving his body to be discovered by investigators days later, authorities say. Keegan Duhaime, 26, was arrested and charged with counts of second-degree murder for allegedly killing Timothy Hill, 72, the New Hampshire Department of Justice announced in press releases.

Officers in the Town of Winchester responded Wednesday shortly after 11:30 a.m. to 484 Scofield Mountain Road to perform a welfare check, prosecutors said.

“Yesterday, just before noontime, officers responded to 484 Scofield Mountain Road for a welfare check,” Senior Assistant Attorney General Geoffrey Ward told WMUR. Those officers found Hill dead in the home.

“Keegan Duhaime, age 26, of Winchester, New Hampshire, has been arrested and charged with one count of second-degree murder for knowingly causing the death of Mr. Hill by shooting him and one count of second-degree murder for recklessly causing the death of Mr. Hill under circumstances manifesting an extreme indifference to the value of human life, by shooting him,” prosecutors wrote.

Online records show authorities booked Duhaime into the Cheshire County Jail early Thursday morning.

Prosecutors described the victim and the defendant as housemates; the two lived together at the 484 Scofield Mountain Road home referenced above.

The autopsy completed on Thursday determined Duhaime fatally shot Hill once in the head, prosecutors said. Authorities say that shooting happened on Saturday, July 9.

Duhaime waived his arraignment on Thursday, and he was ordered held without bail, prosecutors said.

“We’ve identified all of the parties involved, which is important,” Ward said.

The New Hampshire DOJ did not suggest an alleged motive, detail any evidence showing Duhaime is the killer, or lay out a timeline of events.

“Unfortunately our ethical rules and the ongoing investigation in this matter preclude us from providing a comment on any of those questions,” spokesman Michael S. Garrity told Law&Crime.

Indeed, New Hampshire’s ethical rules for attorneys are more strict than those of most other states when it comes to the types of questions attorneys can answer outside of court.

The New Hampshire Public Defender’s office represents Duhaime. It did not immediately respond to a Law&Crime request for comment.  However, a response is unlikely, because New Hampshire’s ethics rules generally ban attorneys from responding to adverse publicity about their clients in the press.

WMUR’s coverage is below:

[Screenshot via WMUR]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: