Skip to main content

N.Y. Ex-Doctor Who Claimed His Wife Died by Slipping in the Shower at Their Palatial Mansion Gets Convicted of Murder After Second Trial

Robert Neulander appears in a march 2022 jail mugshot.

Robert Neulander appears in a march 2022 jail mugshot.

A former upstate New York doctor has reportedly been convicted a second time in the 2012 murder of his wife.  The first conviction was overturned by New York’s highest court after authorities learned that a juror was reading news reports about the case and texting about the proceedings while being repeatedly warned not to do so.

According to reports by the Syracuse Post-Standard and local television stations, a unanimous jury agreed this week that Robert Neulander, now 70, killed his wife Leslie Neulander, then 61, in their 8,000-square-foot mansion in DeWitt.  That locale is a suburb on the east side of Syracuse in the central part of the state.

The Thursday verdict — the one that followed the second trial — came after a reported six hours of deliberations.  The second trial reportedly lasted thirteen days.

Neulander has steadfastly claimed that his wife died by slipping and falling in the shower, according to local news reports.

Longtime Onondaga County District Attorney William Fitzpatrick reportedly told jurors this time around that the slip-and-fall story was “ridiculous,” that the defendant’s timeline didn’t make sense, that the scene was too bloody to be anything but murder, and that the former doctor was “unfaithful.”

Ari Neulander, the son of both the defendant and the victim, told area NBC affiliate WSTM-TV that the conviction was a “travesty of justice.”

The family — and the former doctor’s attorneys — promised yet another appeal.

“We’re going to get him out again, however long that takes,” son Ari told the television station viz. his twice-convicted father.  “We’re going to appeal the decision.”

The son also called top prosecutor Fitzpatrick a “bully,” WSTM noted.

“The district attorney likes to lie,” Ari went on, again according to the NBC affiliate.  “He’s a predator in this community. He is the most dangerous person to anybody in this community.”

Fitzpatrick, a Central New York fixture, has been the elected district attorney since January 1992 and has been with the prosecutor’s office some 45 years, his biography states.

“It’s a sad day,” Fitzpatrick commented after the verdict.  “This man ruined his own family, made [his daughter] Jenna number two in the case, and the irony is Jenna — in her efforts to absolve him — hurt him so badly in the first trial. That’s why they chose to not even call her in the second trial and that hurt him again and that’s how it should be.”

Jenna Neulander was said to have been the “only other person” in the mansion — other than the defendant and the victim, according to the state’s theory — the day her mother died, it has been widely reported.

During the trial, the DA pointed to blood spatter as evidence that the victim was murdered and did not meet her own demise, WSTM indicated during the then-ongoing second case.  The DA also said an expert found a piece of “mummified fat tissue” on the headboard of the victim’s bed just last year — evidence, the DA said, that the victim was murdered.  That piece of evidence was new to the second trial, WSTM noted.

Dr. Neulander was tried and convicted in 2015, but the New York State Court of Appeals set aside the original verdict in 2019 due to what it called “undisputed juror misconduct.”  The Court of Appeals is the highest court in New York State.

The original 2015 verdict came after 18 hours of deliberation spanning four separate days, the Post-Standard newspaper reported.

The “juror misconduct” which resulted in the setting aside of the original guilty verdict was described in detail by the Court of Appeals in its 2019 opinion:

Throughout the trial, one of the jurors, juror 12, sent and received hundreds of text messages about the case. Certain text messages sent and received by juror 12 were troublesome and inconsistent with the trial court’s repeated instructions not to discuss the case with any person and to report any attempts by anyone to discuss the case with a juror. Juror 12 also accessed local media websites that were covering the trial extensively. In order to hide her misconduct, juror 12 lied under oath to the court, deceived the People and the court by providing a false affidavit and tendering doctored text message exchanges in support of that affidavit, selectively deleted other text messages she deemed “problematic,” and deleted her now-irretrievable Internet browsing history. The cumulative effect of juror 12’s extreme deception and dishonesty compels us to conclude that her “improper conduct . . . may have affected a substantial right of the defendant.”

The remedy, the Court of Appeals determined, was a second trial.  The second jury agreed with prosecutors that the defendant was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Neulander surrendered his medical license in 2015, the Post-Standard noted at the time.

Sentencing is for Neulander is scheduled for April 11.  The defendant faces a sentence of 25 years to life in prison.

[image via jail mugshot]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime:

Aaron Keller holds a juris doctor degree from the University of New Hampshire School of Law and a broadcast journalism degree from Syracuse University. He is a former anchor and executive producer for the Law&Crime Network and is now deputy editor-in-chief for the Law&Crime website. DISCLAIMER:  This website is for general informational purposes only. You should not rely on it for legal advice. Reading this site or interacting with the author via this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. This website is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Speak to a competent lawyer in your jurisdiction for legal advice and representation relevant to your situation.