Skip to main content

Manhunt for Double Murder Suspect Who Allegedly Killed His Girlfriend and Her Father Ends in Florida

John Peyton Scott III.

John Peyton Scott III.

A man was arrested less than a day after officials announced him as the suspect who allegedly killed his girlfriend and her father. John Peyton Scott III, 41, is held without bond at the St. Johns County Jail in Florida, online records show.

Authorities across state lines in Alabama say he killed his girlfriend Sharon Tarwater Whited, 40, and her father Chester E. Tarwater Jr., 75, at the home they all lived at in the city of Helena.

Law enforcement’s search for Scott came to an end in St. Johns County, Florida on Monday. Deputies there said they received information that Scott was traveling nearby. According to authorities, they found Scott and performed a PIT maneuver. Scott surrendered immediately, they said.

Last Wednesday afternoon, the elder Tarwater’s 12-year-old grandson found the man dead in the hallway, and investigators later discovered Tarwater Whited dead in a room.

“Her and her dad did not deserve anything like this,” Allison Proctor, a friend of Sharon’s for nine years, told WBMA-LD in a Monday report.

Chester’s wife, who reportedly lives with dementia, was also at the residence, but she sustained no injuries. Sharon was also reportedly the mother of two daughters. The children were not at the residence because they were staying with their father.

“To lose your parent this young, it’s completely robbed of a childhood,” Jason Pruitt, a friend of Sharon’s for 25 years, told WBMA-LD.

Officials initially only called Scott a person of interest.

“Please call us,” Helena Police Department Chief Brad Flynn said in a press conference on Thursday. “We just want to talk to you. We know that he has to be upset and worried, and we want to speak with him and try to arrange a time to sit down and talk.”

Naturally, the tone of that entreaty changed on Sunday night when officials said he was the person who killed his girlfriend and her father.

Scott told the court in an initial court appearance that he needed to speak to counsel before deciding whether to fight extradition to Alabama.

Sharon’s friends described her in glowing terms. She was always smiling, Proctor said. Tarwater Whited often helped at Pruitt’s business Oversoul Brewing, the man said.

“Any time I needed Sharon, I just had to pick up the phone,” he said. “It didn’t matter what it was. When it was. I just had to call her.”

Even their children were close to her family. Proctor said their daughters danced together and had sleepovers. Pruitt likewise said his children were friends with Sharon’s daughters.

“I miss her, and I love her, and I love her family and her kids,” Proctor said. “I know everybody that knew her. Everybody is hurt badly.”

“I’ve always loved her,” Pruitt said. “We’ve always been friends.” He wished he could tell her that again.

[Booking photo via St. Johns County Jail]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: