Skip to main content

Man Pleads Not Guilty After 911 Call Shows Alleged Confession in Baseball Bat Murder of 5-Year-Old Son


Jax Ponomarenko and Matthew J. Ponomarenko

Ohio murder defendant Matthew J. Ponomarenko, 31, pleaded not guilty Friday in an aggravated murder and child endangerment case involving the death of his son Jax Ponomarenko, 5, according to court records reviewed by Law&Crime and the Cleveland Plain Dealer.  But police and prosecutors say a 911 recording from the City of Parma on March 25 contains the defendant’s voice admitting to a dispatcher that he beat the child to death with a baseball bat.

The motive is not clear. The caller said he did not know why he did it and that he had been hearing voices in his head.

[Warning: The content of the audio is disturbing.]

Jax was on the autism spectrum and used a tablet to communicate, uncle Johnathan Cherni told WOIO-TV. He said the defendant, who was recently released from a behavioral health center, seemed fine earlier in the day.

The child’s maternal grandmother asked the court to withhold bond in the case, but the amount was set at $5 million. Cuyahoga County prosecutors are still deciding whether to pursue the death penalty. The local medical examiner formally determined that the cause of Jax’s death was blunt force trauma to the head and that the manner of death was homicide.

“I’m super sad, and you know, mad all at the same time,” neighbor Amanda Bohach told the outlet about the murder last month. “I just realized it just sucks being this close to home and across from a school that’s right over there. The timing is also really bad. Kids were getting off the school bus.”

Online records show the defendant was indicted Tuesday. He previously pleaded no contest to a 2017 child endangerment case in which authorities said he left Jax, then, 1 in the middle of the road, yelled at people, and confessed to cops that he was high on substances such as meth and PCP.

Court records reviewed by Law&Crime say Ponomarenko is charged with two counts of aggravated murder under Ohio law. The first alleges that Ponomarenko “purposefully” cased his son’s death (which is intentional murder); the second alleges Ponomarenko “purposefully” caused the boy’s death “with prior calculation and design” (which is premeditated murder). Ponomarenko is also charged with two counts of child endangerment. One alleges child abuse; the other alleges child torture.

Read the court papers below:

Ohio v Matthew j Ponomarenko by Law&Crime on Scribd

[images via City of Parma, Ohio Police Department]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime: