Skip to main content

Former Massachusetts Middle School Teacher Charged with Raping 13-Year-Old Student Now Faces a Civil Suit


Caitlin Harding

A former Massachusetts middle school teacher previously charged criminally with raping a 13-year-old student now faces a civil lawsuit for similar alleged conduct.

That ex-teacher Caitlin Harding, 37, stands accused of assaulting a student when she was in her early teens in a lawsuit alleging that the town of Hudson, its school district’s then-superintendent Kevin Lyons, then-JFK Middle School Principal Brian Daniels and his assistant Matthew Gaffny let it happen.

“On at least ten occasions in approximately 2010 when plaintiff was approximately thirteen and approximately fourteen years old, defendant Harding engaged in explicit sexual behavior and lewd and lascivious conduct with plaintiff,” the lawsuit states, claiming that Harding kissed her on the lips, fondled her breasts, buttocks, upper inner thighs, and genitals, “both over plaintiff’s clothing and inside.”

The student, whom Law&Crime is not naming as she is an alleged victim of sexual abuse, claims in her complaint that the grooming process began when she was even younger.

When she was between 11 and 12, the student claims, Harding “openly showed affection toward and engaged in physical contact” with her, putting her hand on her arm and shoulder and hugging her, according to the lawsuit.

In the spring of 2019, the student recalled leaving school early to go on vacation when Harding allegedly interrupted a class to say goodbye to her.

“Defendant Harding held Plaintiff in an unusually long and tight hug and rubbed Plaintiff’s back while she said goodbye to Plaintiff in a public area of JFK Middle School,” the complaint states.

During the summer recess between 6th and 7th grade, the student claims she was 12 years old, and Harding allegedly started emailing her. The student claims she was no longer Harding’s student when the teacher repeatedly invited her to visit.

According to the lawsuit, Harding’s attention toward the student started catching the notice of administrators, including Assistant Principal Gaffney and other JFK Middle School staff in a meeting with the student’s parents.

“Following this meeting, plaintiff was assigned to different teachers and moved to different classrooms in another section of JFK Middle School, farther away from defendant Harding’s classroom at the school,” the complaint states.

The student claims she was not the only one perceived to be the object of Harding’s unusual attention.

“Upon information and belief, an administrator or administrators at JFK Middle School conducted a meeting with the parents of at least one other minor girl who was a student at JFK Middle School in response to JFK Middle School administration’s concerns about that girl spending so much time in Defendant Harding’s classroom and Defendant Harding’s attentions to that girl,” according to the lawsuit.

The student accuses the school district of failing to take action.

“JFK Middle School administration and Hudson Public Schools administration apparently failed to investigate or discipline defendant Harding with regard to JFK Middle School administration’s concerns about defendant Harding’s attention to minor girls at JFK Middle School, including plaintiff,” the complaint states.

When charges were first announced against Harding in March, the school district’s current superintendent professed to be “extremely surprised and disappointed” about the revelations.

“At no time during or after her employment have we ever received information indicating that she engaged in any type of conduct that involved potential or actual harm to students,” Hudson Schools Superintendent Marco Rodrigues, who is not a party to this lawsuit, told WBZ-TV in April.

The student says that Harding’s alleged abuse caused her “severe emotional distress and physical harm” such as crying, depression, anxiety, panic attacks, and suicidal ideation.

The seven-count complaint accuses Harding of assault, battery, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and civil rights deprivation. The town of Hudson faces a count of negligent hiring and retention and deprivation of rights. The last count alleges that Superintendent Lyons, Principal Daniels and Assistant Principal Gaffny did not protect her rights.

The student is represented by attorney Mitchell Garabedian, depicted in the film “Spotlight” for his efforts litigating on behalf of thousands of alleged victims of clergy sexual abuse.

(Screenshot from CBS Boston)

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime:

Law&Crime's managing editor Adam Klasfeld has spent more than a decade on the legal beat. Previously a reporter for Courthouse News, he has appeared as a guest on NewsNation, NBC, MSNBC, CBS's "Inside Edition," BBC, NPR, PBS, Sky News, and other networks. His reporting on the trial of Ghislaine Maxwell was featured on the Starz and Channel 4 documentary "Who Is Ghislaine Maxwell?" He is the host of Law&Crime podcast "Objections: with Adam Klasfeld."