Jurors in Palm Beach County, Florida found 26-year-old Christopher Vasata guilty on all charges in the murders of Kelli Doherty, 20, Brandi El-Salhy, 24, and Sean Henry, 26. Prosecutors said Vasata, Marcus Steward, 26, and possibly a third person fatally shot the victims in the backyard of Charles Vorpagel‘s home on February 5, 2017.
According to evidence established in the trial, Vorpagel and Vasata knew each other through the illicit drug trade. Vorpagel was a survivor of the incident and a witness, according to police. As part of the fallout from the case, however, he was convicted on drug and weapons charges. The shootings allegedly happened over a feud.
Assistant State Attorney Jill Richstone told jurors in closing arguments Thursday that El-Salhy was shot four times in the back. Doherty was shot in the face, and other places with an assault rifle. Henry was struck 17 times. Vorpagel was lucky to have survived.
“If that is not premeditation, what is?” she said.
Vasata was convicted of charges including first-degree murder and attempted first-degree murder.
Investigators said they found the defendant near the scene, having been shot. Prosecutors, however, said he was one of the men responsible for what happened. Steward’s case is pending. He would be tried separately, but Richstone argued Thursday that he and the defendant were both responsible for what the other did.
The defense have tried to suggest that another man had more of a motive to commit the slayings.
Public defender Elizabeth Ramsey acknowledged that the state didn’t need to prove motive, but said that this element remained critical. Vasata never previously had a confrontation with Vorpagel, she said. They were friends. He didn’t know El-Salhy and Doherty were going to be there, she argued. She highlighted his injuries, and said that evidence showed Steward helped him from the scene, and saved his life.
[Screengrab via Law&Crime Network]