Nickole Atkinson was the last friend to see Shanann Watts, the pregnant Colorado mom who was brutally murdered along with her two daughters, Bella and Celeste.
Atkinson told “Good Morning America” that she was not surprised to learn that Christopher Watts had been arrested for the murders of his wife and children. Police say he confessed to the murders and hiding the bodies of his young daughters in “mostly full” oil and gas tanks at his workplace property.
The grieving Atkinson explained that she watched Watts’ interview like many others across America have and knew “something was wrong.”
“He was defending himself, but it just didn’t make sense. Like in that moment it is kind of surreal,” she said. “He was just sitting there waiting for something to happen; it just didn’t seem right to me.”
According to ABC News, Watts is expected to be formally charged later Monday.
“He just kept saying that he didn’t know where she was and that she was on a playdate. But he couldn’t give us the name of the friend,” Atkinson continued. “I knew he had something to do with it the day I was at his house with him, but I didn’t want to think that.”
Atkinson went on to say that the couple was “having some issues” around three weeks before the murders and said that Watts “wasn’t being the loving Chris that he normally was.”
“He wasn’t touching or hugging or doing stuff like that. He wasn’t being as attentive to the girls as he normally is,” she said.
Others close to the Watts family were similarly devastated by the news.
Jeremy Lindstrom told Denver7 that the “why” of it all is what he is struggling to understand. Lindstrom had recently hosted the Watts family at a birthday party for his son.
“You know, the hardest part about it all is – when you’re closer to the family … is the ‘why?’” he said. “The why gets bigger.”
“We’re dumbfounded. We don’t get it. Lost,” he added. “It’s just horrible. Why do people do this? Why does it come down to this?”
Neighbor and friend Ashley Bell told CBS4 she couldn’t believe the Christopher Watts she knew could have murdered his family and then gone on television to ask for help in finding them.
“I kept telling myself, no no he wouldn’t do anything to her giving him the benefit of the doubt,” Bell said.
Nick and Amanda Thayer were also blindsided by the news that their friend, Watts, was charged with murder. The couple took Watts in after his family went missing.
Now they’re saying they “feel so stupid […] trusting him to stay the night in the same house as our daughter.”
Amanda Thayer said that their “48-to-72 hours” with Watts “he was his normal self.”
“He never once cried,” she added.
“He fooled us. And I’m so sorry. We just thought we were doing the right thing by being a good friend,” Nick Thayer added. “We were duped.”
On Thursday evening, authorities announced they found the bodies of 4-year-old Bella and 3-year-old Celeste Watts at a property belonging to Anadarko Petroleum, their dad’s now-former employer. It was later reported that their bodies were found in “mostly full” oil and gas tank to hide the smell of decomposing bodies. The bodies were found “in close proximity” to where Shanann Watts was found dead earlier Thursday.
“This is absolutely the worst possible outcome that any of us could imagine,” said John Camper, director for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation.
[Image via Good Morning America screengrab]